Summer and Lewis's conversation and demeanor suggest everything is fine between them but the author keeps saying it's not. Yep we are 16-17 years old and we are just going to go away for a weekend to an inn with our boyfriend.ġ5. And so what if she's neat now that she's out? That isn't necessarily a bad quality.ġ4. Summer always commented that the cellar was actually too clean. Since when was Summer beaten for not cleaning up after herself? That was never mentioned in The Cellar plus Rose would never have let that happen. They were together in the last book but this book puts them together later. Chantelle didn't deserve to die but all of girls you killed in the past did? Including Mandy who wasn't even a prostitute?! THIS BOOK SUCKS SO BAD.ġ2. He's just talking so normally to Chantelle. So Clover is all of the sudden okay with talking to a prostitute about his life story.

So no one cares that Lewis and Summer sleep in the same bed now?ġ0. When could she have possibly done all of that?ĩ. Yet Becca had already found Clover's mom and dad and gotten the same amount of sleep. She got three hours of sleep after going to Clover's house. She keeps calling Violet, Louise in this book but in the last book I thought her name was Layal.Ĩ. The author glazes over the sexual parts with the flowers.ħ. And like if him and his mom were together sexually then he should have more sexual desires with the girls. That tells and doesn't show us exactly what she means. The authors note at the end of chapter 4 about her clearing up that Clover and his mom were REALLY close. Mandy, you had so many opportunities to freaking run.ĥ. The police are waiting at Clover's to see if he comes home but Summer and Becca just waltz in without police knowledge.Ĥ. How did the wreck in the beginning even happen?ģ.

The only reason I read the whole thing was to see what happened to Summer.ġ. If I could give this a negative star rating I would. ***This review was written before the book was edited, I’m pretty sure.

The cellar by natasha preston